While the rent roll market remains active, make no mistake it remains competitive, with buyers becoming increasingly selective, financiers are scrutinising portfolios more closely, and due diligence standards continue to rise.

This is Part 2 of our three-part series, 5 Common Mishaps in a Rent Roll Transaction. In Part 1, we explored due diligence from the buyer’s perspective. This time, we’re focusing on the seller and some of the most common issues we see create unnecessary problems during the sale process.

While most discussions around rent roll sales focus on price and multipliers, the reality is that many transactions encounter avoidable issues well before settlement.

Below are the five issues we see most often during a rent roll sale transaction.

 

1. lack of preparation before sale

 

One of the most common issues is sellers going to market before their portfolio is properly prepared.

At the centre of this is usually administration and compliance, particularly Form 6 appointment forms.

Buyers want to see:

  • compliant Form 6s
  • current fee structures reflected correctly
  • accurate landlord records
  • organised property files
  • clear trust accounting records
  • documented systems and processes

Importantly, buyers are not the only parties reviewing this information. Financiers are also focused on compliance and may refuse to lend against managements where compliant authorities cannot be demonstrated.

While the rent roll market is competitive, buyers and banks will not tolerate messy portfolios. In some cases, this can result in:

  • reduced pricing multiple
  • longer retention periods
  • properties being excluded from the sale
  • transaction delays
  • buyers withdrawing altogether

As a starting point, sellers should take a buyer’s view of their own business.

Ask yourself:

If I was buying this rent roll, would the records give me confidence?

Even experienced agencies can have small compliance issues creep in over time. We regularly recommend sellers undertake pre-sale due diligence or have an independent consultant review a sample of their Form 6s prior to going to market.

Relative to the value of most rent rolls, this is usually a modest investment that can materially improve transaction outcomes.

 

2. underestimating the sale time frame

 

Another common mistake is assuming a rent roll transaction will progress like a residential property sale.

It won’t.

Rent roll transactions are significantly more complex and involve a range of moving parts including:

  • buyer qualification
  • finance approval
  • legal review
  • due diligence
  • Form 6 verification
  • retention negotiations
  • staff considerations
  • landlord communication
  • settlement logistics

Even straightforward transactions can take several months from preparation through to settlement.

Where sellers encounter problems is when they leave the process too late or work toward unrealistic timeframes. This can create pressure around negotiations and reduce flexibility if issues arise during due diligence.

A well-prepared sale process almost always produces a better outcome than a rushed transaction.

 

3. not having advisors who understand rent roll transactions

 

Rent roll sales are highly specialised transactions.

While many advisors may understand business sales generally, rent rolls involve specific operational, legal and compliance considerations that differ from other industries.

This includes:

  • industry valuation/pricing methodology
  • retention conditions
  • appointment compliance
  • trust accounting considerations
  • landlord concentration risk
  • property management operations

Using advisors without rent roll transaction experience can create unnecessary complications during the sale process.

Experienced advisors understand what buyers, financiers and lawyers are likely to focus on during the transaction. Often, identifying issues early is what prevents delays later in the process.

 

4. trying to do it yourself

 

Many owners consider selling privately in an effort to save fees or maintain control of the process.

In reality, this often becomes more difficult than expected.

A rent roll transaction requires ongoing coordination between:

  • buyers
  • accountants
  • lawyers
  • financiers
  • staff
  • landlords

Remembering that at the same time, the seller is still attempting to run their business day-to-day while juggling a range of sale transaction issues, including:

  • pricing expectations
  • confidentiality
  • buyer qualification
  • due diligence management
  • retention negotiations
  • transaction structure
  • settlement preparation

And the more emotionally invested you become in the idea of selling, the easier it is for the deal to move along before you have properly considered your options. Importantly, many problems outlined in points two and three become amplified when transactions are handled without specialist guidance.

Selling a rent roll is not simply about finding a buyer. The real work is often in managing the process from initial discussions through to successful settlement.

 

5. unreasonable expectations

 

Unreasonable or unrealistic expectations can create problems for both sellers and buyers.

From a seller’s perspective, this may involve:

  • unrealistic pricing expectations
  • overlooking compliance concerns
  • assuming all management income is of the same quality
  • assuming there will only be limited negotiation of the sale contract [this isn’t like selling a house]

From a buyer’s perspective, it can include:

  • unrealistic pricing expectations
  • unreasonable retention expectations
  • expecting perfect compliance across every management file

Retention arrangements are a common example.

While retention protection is an industry expectation, arrangements still need to remain commercially reasonable. Attempts to overreach on contract terms can create tension between buyer and seller during transition.

Ultimately, successful transactions occur where expectations are grounded in operational reality with a focus on practical commercial outcomes:

 

final takeaway

 

Most rent roll transactions that experience difficulties tend to suffer from the same underlying issue, a lack of preparation.

Preparing your portfolio properly before sale, understanding realistic transaction timeframes, and engaging advisors experienced in rent roll transactions can significantly improve both the sale experience and the eventual outcome.

Importantly, good preparation is not just about maximising price. It can also help:

  • reduce retention risk
  • simplify due diligence
  • improve buyer confidence
  • minimise transaction delays
  • increase the likelihood of reaching settlement successfully

As the market develops, buyers are increasingly focused on portfolio quality, compliance and operational strength. Sellers who understand this and prepare accordingly will generally place themselves in the strongest position when it comes time to sell.

 

we’re here to help!

We hope you’ve found this series helpful in giving you a clearer picture of how rent roll transactions work and the key pitfalls to look out for.

If you’re thinking about buying or selling a rent roll management portfolio, our rent roll sales team are here to help. Give us a buzz on 1300BDEPOT or email agencybroking@businessdepot.com.au

 

continue the series

part 1 ← previous article

 

get more insights

Want to hear more about all things broking? You can sign up for our mailing list below!

 


 

general advice disclaimer

The information provided on this website is a brief overview and does not constitute any type of advice. We endeavour to ensure that the information provided is accurate however information may become outdated as legislation, policies, regulations and other considerations constantly change. Individuals must not rely on this information to make a financial, investment or legal decision. Please consult with an appropriate professional before making any decision.